Classic proportions to this drink are most often quoted as being: 1 rum, 1 cognac, 1 triple sec and 1/4 lemon juice but three shots of 40% alcohol and a splash. The Between the Sheets starts as a Sidecar but diverges with a measure of light rum and skips the customary sugared rim. Between The Sheets Here's a cocktail that combines two base spirits, brandy and rum. It's a prohibition era recipe that takes inspiration from the Sidecar, a. The Between the Sheets is a cocktail consisting of white rum (or other light rum), cognac, triple sec, and lemon juice. When made with gin, instead of rum. Between the Sheets is a rum cocktail with Cognac, orange liqueur and lemon juice. It's a spin off on the classic Sidecar, likely invented in the. Another classical coctail, which have some ambiguous name and bright taste. Between the Sheets. 20 ml light rum. Most people call this cocktail Between the Sheets, though you may hear it referred to as a Maiden's Prayer as well. Between the Sheets adds rum to the mix for an extra fillip of flavor. Having two base spirits in a drink is a bit unusual (most cocktails. the Between the Sheets takes the classic trio of cognac, lemon, and orange liqueur and tinkers with the flavor by swapping out part of. Between the Sheets is a cocktail made with lemon juice and equal parts cognac, rum, and Cointreau. The ingredients are shaken with ice, and then strained.